Home» Insights» Articles

Adult Learning Theory: How to Design Better Workplace Training

Articles

When a workplace procedure changes, everyone affected needs to understand the new requirements and what they must do differently. Communicating the change is the first step, but employees may need different levels of instruction and practice to follow the revised procedure correctly. Those familiar with the procedure may need to adjust established habits, while newer employees may require more guidance. The expected standard remains the same for everyone.

Adult learning theory can inform these training decisions by highlighting employees’ prior knowledge and how much they can take responsibility for their learning. However, the level of guidance provided should reflect what employees already understand and can demonstrate, rather than assumptions based on their experience.

Adult Learning Theory and the Limits of Andragogy

Adult learning theories examine how people acquire knowledge and develop skills. One influential approach is andragogy, associated with educational researcher Malcolm Knowles. He proposed that adults bring experience to learning, want to understand its relevance and often prefer some responsibility for how they learn.

David Kaufman’s review of educational theory in the BMJ examines how Knowles adult learning theory can inform teaching. Its underlying assumptions can guide training design, but should not be treated as fixed characteristics of every adult. Kaufman’s discussion is grounded in medical education rather than a tested method for workplace training.

In The Adult Learner: A Mythical Species, G. R. Norman questioned whether adults learn in fundamentally different ways from younger learners. He also argued that developing self-directed learning skills does not necessarily improve competence in the subject being studied.

How Prior Knowledge Affects Training Design

When an organisation updates its purchasing approval procedure, employees who regularly prepare purchase requests may already know which documents are required and how to submit them. However, they may still be accustomed to the previous approval rules. For a new recruit, preparing a purchase request may be unfamiliar.

Adult learning theory encourages designers to account for existing knowledge when introducing new requirements. The National Academies’ How People Learn II explains that what people already know can make new information easier to understand. However, established routines may also lead employees to overlook changes or rely on outdated rules.

Once the L&D team explains the revised procedure, it could use a few sample purchasing requests to assess employees’ understanding of the new approval rules. Asking employees to identify which requests require additional approval would help reveal where further instruction or practice is needed.

Employees who clearly understand the new rules may be ready to work through more complex scenarios. Those who continue applying the previous rules may need additional guidance on what has changed. New recruits, meanwhile, may need instruction on the purchasing process before they can confidently assess approval requirements.

The training can then be organised around the gaps identified in employees’ responses, rather than assumptions about what they know based on their roles or length of service.

Learner Choice and Workplace Requirements

Knowles’ adult learning principles suggest that adults often prefer some control over how they learn. For L&D teams, the challenge is deciding where that independence is appropriate. Employees may choose to review an explanation before attempting a practical task or try the task first and refer to the guidance afterwards. However, the workplace requirements they must learn to follow remain the same.

In the purchasing approval example, an employee who understands the revised procedure may not need to complete every introductory activity. They should still be able to demonstrate that they can apply the current approval rules, including any exceptions. Allowing employees greater independence in how they learn should not mean reducing the standard they are expected to meet.

Feedback is also important when employees are given greater control over their learning. Someone who attempts a task independently may overlook an approval condition without realising it. Clear feedback can explain the mistake and direct them towards the relevant guidance before they try again. L&D teams therefore need to consider both the choices available to learners and the support they need to make progress.

Practise the Decisions Employees Will Make

Once employees have been introduced to the revised purchasing procedure, training should give them opportunities to apply the new approval rules. Knowing how to complete a request form does not necessarily mean knowing when additional approval is required.

A practice activity could present employees with similar purchasing requests that require different approval routes. They would need to decide how to handle each request and explain which part of the revised procedure applies. Feedback could identify overlooked conditions and give employees a chance to work through another example, rather than only telling them whether their answer was correct.

The National Academies’ How People Learn II discusses two approaches that can support long-term retention: retrieval practice and spaced practice. Retrieval practice involves recalling previously learned information from memory, rather than repeatedly reviewing the material. Spaced practice involves returning to that information at intervals, instead of concentrating all learning activities into a single session. Both approaches give employees further opportunities to reinforce what they have learned.

For the purchasing procedure, employees could be asked to recall an approval condition several days after their initial training and apply it to a different request. This would provide an opportunity to check whether they can remember the revised rule after a delay and use it in another situation.

The examples used in training and the feedback employees receive should reflect the decisions they will need to make when applying the procedure. We examine the wider development of learning materials in our article, Content Design: Creating Learning That Sticks.

Training Transfer: Applying Learning at Work

Completing a training exercise correctly does not necessarily mean an employee will apply what they have learned consistently at work. This is the challenge of training transfer: using knowledge and skills acquired during training when carrying out normal workplace tasks. An employee may select the correct approval route during an exercise but struggle with an unfamiliar request when applying the procedure in practice.

Research suggests that the workplace environment also influences whether learning is applied. In a 2010 meta-analysis published in the Journal of Management, Blume and colleagues examined findings from 89 studies of training transfer. They found positive associations between learning application and factors such as employee motivation and a supportive work environment. Although these relationships suggest that workplace conditions matter, the findings do not establish that any particular support measure will improve performance in every organisation.

Workplace Support After Training

For the revised purchasing procedure, employees may need access to clear, up-to-date guidance and opportunities to ask managers about requests that fall outside the examples covered in training. Managers could also review a sample of purchasing decisions after the new rules take effect to identify recurring errors. Where appropriate, L&D teams could compare these observations with assessment results to see whether difficulties identified during training continue in the workplace.

The reasons behind those difficulties also matter. An incorrect approval decision may indicate that an employee has misunderstood the revised requirements. However, recurring errors could also point to unclear instructions or inconsistencies in how the procedure is applied. Further training may address gaps in understanding, but problems with the procedure itself would require a different response.

Reviewing purchasing decisions after training may reveal problems that were not apparent during the course. For example, if several employees continue to misunderstand the same approval condition, the L&D team could review how that requirement was explained and practised. SureSkills’ Corporate Curriculum Development guide discusses using evidence of workplace performance to review and improve training programmes.

Adult learning theory is useful when it informs specific decisions about instruction and learner independence. Employees may need different training routes, but each must understand their role requirements and show they can apply them. Evidence gathered during training and subsequent workplace activity should guide any further instruction or support.

SureSkills’ Managed Learning Services include custom eLearning development and programme management. Organisations reviewing how their training accommodates different levels of employee experience can speak to SureSkills about their learning development requirements.